- Father Rob Keighron — Already drinking a Blue Moon. He calls out Lino for ragging on him for drinking too much. Lino apologizes.
- Paul in Illinois — Chooses to drink a Bud Light. He won both a rose-scented rosary and a Mark Hart book on Let's Make A Catholic Deal but has not received either. Lino calls Jared on the carpet for not sending out prizes; Jared attempts to reconcile simply by drinking beer. Jared them promises to send the rosary out right away and the book as soon as he gets it from Mark. Lino proposes that Paul call in to the show every day until he receives his prizes. (NOTE: Lino Watch will be happy to run another Jared countdown on the site if Paul actually does call in each day.)
- Vindictive Vince — Apologizes to Lino for all the times he called him out and aggravated him with his humor. Asks Lino to reciprocate for the times he called him out and hung up on him, and for nicknaming him Vindicive Vince. Lino does so only after Fr. Rob says he has to. Chooses to drink a Blue Moon.
- Gus Lloyd, host of the awesome morning show Seize The Day — Way too much to write. Chooses to drink a Diet Dr. Pepper; thought that Lino should've had a Dos Equis instead of a Bud Light. Listen to the entire clip below (coming soon).
- Amadeo in Temecula, California — Asks to trade Lino's reconciliation for a trip blessing from Father Ron. Lino then asks him to reconcile with Father Rob for calling him Father Ron. Lino promised to bring him a little bottle of wine from his hotel room's minibar during his trip to Rome last December. He didn't. Lino apologizes, and Amadeo gets a blessing from Father Rob.
- dustin in Mansfield, Arkansas — Apologizes to Lou for sending an e-mail to the show insinuating that Mark Hart was more important to the show that Lou. Lou accepts apology. Then apologizes to Lino for not updating CatholicGuyShow.com as often as he should, and for getting critical of him when he does. Lino then goes off on dustin about the quality/timeliness of the site and how it makes baby Jesus (and sometimes Lou) cry. Lino accepts dustin's apology, and makes him apologize again for his site as he resolves to improve it somewhat. Then he gets in another jab at dustin by alluding that Lino Watch has been picking up the pace recently in terms of updates. (Lino Watch does not take any pleasure in the excoriation of CatholicGuyShow.com, although it does appreciate the shameless plug for Lino Watch that resulted.) Chooses to bring his own Sam Adams instead of one of the other beers offered. Lino gets upset, and dustin relents and chooses Blue Moon. Lino hangs up on dustin.
- "Crazy" Cathy in Woodbury, Minnesota — You knew this was coming. Cathy starts listing Lino's many sins, including getting put on hold. Lino promptly puts Cathy on hold and goes on to the next caller. (There's more of Cathy below.)
- Kimberly in Fairfax, Virginia — Lino inferred during an installment of Let's Make A Catholic Deal that Kimberly was a pothead because she grew up in the 70s. Lino apologizes after hemming and hawing a bit, then asks the 70s to apologize to everyone. Also complains about not receiving the Popener she won; Lino promptly yells at Jared. Asked to choose a beer, Kimberly complains about the choices. Lino yells at her, then she chooses Sam Adams, at which point Lino hangs up on her.
- Cathy (Part II) — Just listen to the clip (coming soon). Basically they end up apologizing that the other's actions cause them to act badly. Chooses to drink Bud Light but reconsiders after hearing that it's the same thing Lino's drinking.
- Alex in Kansas City, Kansas — Tells Lino that the show is so funny that his coworkers are staring at him as he laughs like a girl; wants Lino to apologize. Lino apologizes for having such an entertaining show. Chooses to drink a Hamm's and uses Scripture to justify choosing a beer that's not in Lino's list.
- Bad Connection Bob — Apologizes for his bad connections (just as he has a bad connection). Lino apologizes for spending about five seconds talking with him at the Eucharistic Congress in Atlanta after he drove 800 miles to be there. Chooses to drink a Red Stripe.
- Tony in Fort Dix, New Jersey -- Apologizes for being in his office, in uniform, drinking a beer while listening to the show. Is drinking a Peroni, which despite not being on the list is accepted by Lino because it's Italian.